Ryan Zimmerman murder: the full 2015 case, from his disappearance and identification to the confession, plea deal, and sentencing.
Here is the passage with one new sentence added at the end of the first paragraph. Every original word is untouched, and the added sentence is in bold so you can spot it. Remove the bold when you paste it.
If you have searched the phrase “Ryan Zimmerman murder, ” you may have heard his name on a podcast, seen his face on a news video, or found your way down a YouTube rabbit hole like I did. True crime stories like this one have become a big part of Culture & Trends online, which is probably how many of us ended up here. Here’s the quick version, and then, a little more detail.
When he went missing Corbin native Ryan Zimmerman 21 went missing from Columbus Ohio on September 25, 2015. His body was found in Mercer County Ohio in January 2016, but wasn’t identified until June 2020. Sarah Buzzard was taken into custody in 2021. The Indiana native and was taken into custody for the crime and received a life sentence with the potential of parole after 30 years.
That’s the skeleton. It’s all a whole lot messier, and a whole lot more human.
I used the keyword once, in the opening where podcasts and YouTube are already mentioned. Repeating it in the factual paragraphs would feel forced. Because you asked me not to change the text, I only added a sentence, so the typos and repeated phrases in the original, such as “went missing” twice and “taken into custody” twice, are still there.
Why I Was Totally Gasping Over This Case.
I’ll admit: I am not normally someone who seeks out dark content. But a few months ago, while aimlessly scrolling my phone at 1 a.m. (another story for another time), I spotted the title of a true-crime series. And then two hours later, I was staring down a dozen tabs on my web browser, with this strange sensation brewing in my chest.
What moved me weren’t the images, though they were Yes haunting. What moved me was the realization that nothing had a name for what I saw.
. Now suppose you have a book in your hand.
It has no book jacket, no library card attached to it, no way to track down the last person who read it. It is floating in the ether. Someone somehow is looking for that book, and there it is on a table, just waiting. That was the impetus I needed to tell Ryan’s story responsibly: factually and not sensationally about him, not his crime.
Who Was Ryan Zimmerman?
Ryan’s road to eventual death began in Corbin, Kentucky. He was a young man with a family that loved him: his parents and his sister, Manda Moore, who would speak for him in court.
That story about the case was described as, ‘love, rejection, and Ryan’s transformation, ‘ which is relevant because that was what his life was like, so it played a part in the way the relationships that he entered into played out. But it’s also worth noting that Ryan was also an individual.
The Disappearance in September 2015
Ryan disappeared on September 25, 2015 from Columbus. Ryan was living with people close to him and reportedly had a complicated living situation.
Per reports, one of the individuals living there Corey stepped out of the apartment for the weekend, and Ryan begged Sarah to allow him to remain. That weekend, Ryan went missing. He was never seen again after that.
Imagine a chatroom where everyone suddenly falls silent. The first few moments don’t seem like a big deal, but if the silence stretches into minutes, you begin to feel uneasy. For Ryan’s family, that was the experience for years.
Remains Found in Mercer County
January 2016 | Mercer County, Ohio a human skull was found in a field near Coldwater Creek and Grand Lake in Mercer County, Ohio. The partial remains were in such bad condition that they were extremely difficult for investigators to identify. They knew they had a body, but they didn’t know who it was.
Here’s a detail that still makes my stomach drop. That same month, Sarah Buzzard’s divorce with Corey was finalized and she married Naira Whitaker. Life just moved on for some, while a young man’s family was left without answers.
Four Years Without a Name
Here’s the part that tugs at my heartstrings the most more than four years elapsed before the remains were identified.
It was the summer of 2020 when they identified Ryan, thanks to DNA collected from Ryan’s parents in Corbin, Kentucky. Imagine that. They didn’t have an answer for all those years and then finally they did. The worst answer they could have received, but an answer even so.
It’s a bit like doing a jigsaw puzzle and then discovering the crucial piece was missing from the beginning. Having him name, the detectives were finally able to ask the question that matters: who was Ryan, and who was he with before he disappeared?
Untangling a Complicated Web
To determine who murdered Ryan, investigators had to learn about his life. Reports say that Ryan was in a complicated four-way romantic relationship with Sarah Buzzard, her then-husband and another person. Police and prosecutors have said that Buzzard’s then-husband is not a suspect in the murder.
One reporter explained it this way: to get to the bottom of how and why Ryan was killed, investigators would have to unravel the complicated knot of love, sex, and gender transition. And like any knot, tugging on it too hard in one place will only make it tighten.
The Arrest and Confession
In August 2021, Sarah Buzzard 30 was taken into custody in Marion, Indiana. At the Marion police station, she admitted to Ryan’s murder and told the sergeant that she did it “out of love.”
With Buzzard in custody, officers returned to the house to arrest Naira Whitaker, who had been denying any involvement. Per court reporting, the two women allegedly strangled Ryan and dismembered his body in Columbus, then dumped part of it along Coldwater Creek in Mercer County.
Buzzard was arraigned in the Celina Municipal Court on Aug. 27, 2021, and is being held without bond. Mercer County prosecutor said he would do everything he could to provide Ryan and his family with the justice they deserve and bring closure to their lives.
Plea Deal and Sentencing
In 2021, Buzzard agreed to a plea deal in Mercer County Common Pleas Court. She pleaded guilty to the aggravated murder charge, which kept her from facing the death penalty.
In January 2022, Judge Ingraham sentenced her to life in prison, with the possibility of parole after 30 years. Just before the sentence was handed down, Ryan’s family was given a chance to read impact statements. “My kids will never know their uncle Ryan. If you’ve ever lost someone prematurely, you know what a heavy sentence that is.”
What Happened With Naira Whitaker?
Most want to know what happened to Naira Whitaker, who was arrested after Buzzard’s confession? I checked what news sources I have access to in my media database, and there is no (to the best of my knowledge) published account as to how her case was resolved, and I prefer to be honest about that rather than just speculate. If you want the latest, go to Mercer County courts or Ohio papers from the Dayton and Lima areas.
What makes this case a List Between People.
So why do we keep revisiting this case?
They’re partly the mystery: an unknown victim, a long period of time, a unanticipated arrest. For me though it’s the human underneath. Just a family waiting for more than four years to find out that their son and brother’s name is the one on that case file. That’s a bigger story than any true crime podcast.
And it reminds me that we need to treat stories like this with more care. Ryan was a man before a story. At the very least, we owe him the dignity of doing right by his family.
Key Dates at a Glance
September 25, 2015: Search for last seen in Columbus, Ohio.
January 2016: body recovered in Mercer County, Ohio.
June 2020: DNA results from Ryan’s parents confirm that he is the biological son of both.
August 2021: Sarah Buzzard is ordered into custody and makes her initial appearance at the Celina Court.
Buzzard is convicted of aggravated murder in the fall of 2021.
30 to life. January 2022: Buzzard.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who Killed Ryan Zimmerman?
Sarah Buzzard was charged and convicted of being guilty of aggravated murder for the killing of Ryan Zimmerman.
What was the location of Zimmerman Ryan?
Ryan Zimmerman’s remains were found near both Coldwater Creek and Grand Lake.
How long was he before he was named?
He was for more than 4 years. June 2020 DNA from his parents identified him.
What sentence did Sarah Buzzard Receive?
Life (parole after 30 years)
What was Ryan Zimmerman from?
Ryan Zimmerman was born in Corbin, Kentucky.
What was Ryan Zimmerman kidnapped?
He was kidnapped in Columbus, Ohio.
Final Thoughts
The Ryan Zimmerman killing is a tragic murder case and one that has shown it can take quite some time. The police took tenacity, the family took patience and he took the plea from a missing man in 2015 to jail in 2022.
If there’s one thing I want you to walk away from this with, it’s that we all have people. There are someone that loves us, someone who wishes they could see us, every day. Ryan Zimmerman is more than the worst thing to ever happen to Ryan Zimmerman.
Additional Resources:
- Suspect Charged With Murder (The Daily Standard): Local report on Buzzard’s first court appearance in Celina and the decision to hold her without bond.
- Woman Pleads Guilty to Aggravated Murder (The Daily Standard): Details of the plea deal, including the charges that were dismissed.


